American Idol’s Carrie Underwood has received criticism from audiences, and her costars seem just as disappointed with her judging abilities.

Carrie Underwood had a hilarious reaction to one of Simon Cowell's more brutal critiques she got during her time on American ...

ABC's American Idol continues its Top 24 performances from Hawaii on Monday, though many fans called out the judges panel.

According to a source, ABC didn't necessarily choose Carrie Underwood as their first choice to judge in 'American Idol' ...

"(Underwood said) 'I don’t want any of them to leave!' 'Carrie, we’ve got a minute left. What is the answer?'" He adds, "This is her first time around, and she's on this side of the judges ...

In a recent video, Carrie Underwood reacts to an old clip from American Idol that shows Simon Cowell critiquing her Top Five ...

Carrie Underwood took a heartfelt trip down memory ... Idol's most successful contestants She continued to share how the judges reacted to her performance, reflecting on their praise with obvious ...

Carrie Underwood‘s flawless performances during season 4 of “American Idol” resulted in her winning the competition. The ...

The 42-year-old Underwood - who won American Idol 20 years ago - joined the judges table this season ... Lionel and Luke were on board, but Carrie was the most vocal about wanting it to make ...

Carrie Underwood agreed with her fellow American Idol judges about two singers they saved on Monday night. The other two were trickier. After the show, she admitted to experiencing some amount of ...

Carrie Underwood might not return as an American Idol judge after Season 23. Pic credit: ABC Carrie Underwood’s return as an American Idol judge was considered a significant move for the singing ...