Over the past decade, proportionality has become a defining feature of federal discovery practice, particularly in the context of electronically stored information (ESI). The 2015 amendments to the ...

I recently explained how the decision is patently narrow, applying only to age-verification mandates targeting access to sexual content that, in Justice Clarence Thomas’s words for the majority, “the ...

A major theme of the discovery-related 2015 amendments to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure was the reintroduction of proportionality as a core aspect of the permissible scope of discovery. As ...

Redistricting, the process of drawing congressional and state legislative districts, is all about making choices and setting priorities. Gov. Mike DeWine says the priorities laid out in State Issue 1, ...